Saab: Need Some Advice on Charging System Saab 9000
-
Need Some Advice on Charging System Saab 9000
Every day last week after work, ( last week was a cold week) I barely had
enough battery reserve to spin over the engine. Luckily after a few short
groans it always started. Each time, before cranking, the in dash digital
voltmeter was in the 11.5 to 12.0 range ( not pretty). Each night I put it
on a charger and in the morning, I had power to spare. On Wed it was in the
shop and I was told that there was nothing wrong with the charging system or
the battery. All connections have been cleaned and tightened. The battery
is 12 months old and is an 850 CCA . I tried to get a replacement as the
batterty has a 6 yr warranty with a no cost replacement for 24 months. The
garage refued, saying that the battery load tested fine and that the problem
had to be with the car......however....no problem could be found with the
car ( catch 22) . The drain on the battery with the car parked,( alarm not
set) was 50 milliamps. That certainly is not the problem. I insisted that
this problem was directly related to the cold, not the car. The output of
the alternator is a steady 14.2 - 14.3 with lights ,heater and sound system
etc all on.
Right now I have the battery cable lifted and an ammeter hooked up in
series. I am only seeing the same 50 milliamp draw. I turned various
accessories on and off to see if anything was staying energized but the load
always returned to 50 milliamps. I have been monitoring for about 3 hours
and all is still well. I just opened my garage door so the temp will fall
to -16. I will monitor the drain throughout the night and see if the drain
changes. I am not sure what to do next except maybe I should go to a
different garage where I will probably have to buy a new battery and forget
my warranty.
One thing that I did notice that was my fuel pump really sucks down my
battery. If the car has been parked for a few hours, the fuel pump will cut
in as soon as the key is in the on position. I noticed that it pulls the
battery voltage down by .5 volts. That pump must pull some serious current.
I dare not try to measure it as my meter is only rated for 10 amps. The pump
is fused at 20.
Any ideas of what I can do myself before going off to another garage??
-
Re: Need Some Advice on Charging System Saab 9000
On Sat, 17 Jan 2004 19:07:32 GMT, in alt.autos.saab you wrote:
If that's before cranking, then something is a bit wrong, although 12
volts is the nominal voltage, it's really happier at a bit more than
that.
Bet this was in a nice warm shop, wasn't it?
So no alternator problems, although I think the voltage is a bit high,
but not by much. 14.2 volts is about 2.36 volts/cell, and that's just
fine for charging, but it's trying to charge. (normal rest voltage is
about 2.2 volts/cell for floating, iirc). That's where the 13.8 volts
for mobile radio equipment comes in.
I suspect that you might be having a temperature problem with the
battery. I'd take an analog voltmeter (unless yours can measure and
hold a minimum) and then measure the voltage:
1) open circuit without the key in the ignition.
2) key in, off position
3) key in, run position
4) key in, start position
Voltage on the average battery under those circumstances can be as
little as about 8 to 9 volts while cranking.
If the battery goes down by 0.5 volts on a 15 to 20 amp load, that's
perhaps a bit much, although it might be average. That says that the
internal resistance is about .0333 ohms, which will drop 5 volts
(assuming nothing else drops anything) at 150 amps. However much the
starter is rated at, will give you an idea. That would get you from
12 down to 7, or the nominal 13.8 down to 8.8.
I'm thinking that the battery has a cold problem.
If you can, measure the specific gravity in the morning, which will
also tell you if you are getting a full charge. Get something with a
gauge on it, not the silly little balls.
If all else fails, you can get a battery tester at Harbor Freight
(only if on sale)... or go to an autozone or battery store which often
has a battery checker. Of course, you don't want to be driving the
car there...
In removing the battery, always remove the - lead first, that way, the
only thing you have to worry about is touching the - terminal with the
wrench. If you try to remove the + lead first, touching the engine
with the wrench will short out the battery.
Hope that this helps.
Harvey.
-
Re: Need Some Advice on Charging System Saab 9000
Well I made it through the night without detecting any appreciable drain
from the battery ( stayed steady at 50 milliamps as expected). The temp hit
a crispy low of -16. This morning when I turned the key, the in-dash volt
momentary flashed at 12.3 and instantly dropped to 11.8. When I cranked the
engine it dropped to 9.5 and did not sound too happy about it. All these
slow grinding starts cant be good for my starter, unless it is part of the
problem. Tomorrow I will return to my garage and grovel for a new
replacement battery. Wish me luck.
"Radar166" <com> wrote in message
news:UJfOb.68755$bloor.is.net.cable.rogers.com...
the
or
problem
not
system
load
forget
cut
current.
pump
-
Re: Need Some Advice on Charging System Saab 9000
On Sun, 18 Jan 2004 21:15:18 GMT, "Radar166" <com>
wrote:
9.5 volts is pretty close to the appropriate voltage. You might want
to check what the nominal voltage when starting should be. I'm not
sure, otherwise, I'd mention it.
Does it crank faster with a booster battery?
Could you be using a viscous oil (such as 10W-40 rather than 5W-40),
lower than is recommended for your car at -16? These could have an
affect as well.
Harvey
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
Forum Rules